Sticky wicket: How Cricket Australia can navigate a reputational meltdown

18 Nov 2026

New revelations surrounding the Sandpapergate scandal have captured global headlines and exposed fissures across the Australian cricketing world. Lawrence Dore, Joe Rooke and Tom Fisher explore how we got here and how Cricket Australia might begin to contain and repair the damage.

It is March 2018, when Australian cricket international Cameron Bancroft is caught on the big screen at Newlands Cricket Ground in Cape Town, not so much with his trousers down as with sandpaper down his trousers.

Therein followed a swift set of apologies and admissions of ball tampering by Bancroft and senior members of the squad. An immediate investigation by Cricket Australia would see national team captain and vice-captain Steve Smith and David Warner stripped of their titles and ultimately banned, alongside Bancroft.

The rapid fallout would also see head coach Darren Lehmann resign, and Cricket Australia chief executive and chairman James Sutherland and David Peever both stepping down, following the findings of an independent cultural review in October of the same year. Then Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull calls the whole affair a “disgrace.”

Since then, however, the casual observer might have been forgiven for thinking the affair resolved. The guilty parties appeared to have been punished or resigned and, certainly by 2026, the Australian cricket team largely seemed to have moved on. Present captain Pat Cummins said as much in October of this year.

Back around the wicket

But not two weeks ago, promoting his new autobiography, recently retired player Usman Khawaja pitched bombshell allegations. According to the former batsman, the whole team knew and was in on the ball-tampering and rejected opportunities to take collective responsibility. He also alleged they had ball tampered without detection in the Test match prior to Cape Town, in Port Elizabeth.

The allegations have left Australian cricket reeling, with former and current coaches, players and executives all positioning themselves on opposite ends of the wicket.

Cummins has stood by comments he made in 2021, refuting his own involvement as well as any suggestion of a “master plan” administered by the whole team. In a mammoth press conference, Cummins also accused Khawaja of being “casual” with his life, that of others and of Australian cricket.

Warner, on the other hand, has come out in full support of Khawaja, further alleging that the initial 2018 investigation was full of holes and stank of a “cover-up.” Bancroft, too, whose butterfingers kicked off the affair, has, just at the time of writing, said the whole team knew and that he feels “betrayed” by the captain’s continued pleas of innocence. Appearing to confirm Warner’s allegations around the integrity of Cricket Australia’s initial investigation, he has alleged he “did not give a complete and truthful account” as part of his own testimony in 2018, in order to protect the investigation and his teammates.

The interim chairman of Cricket Australia, meanwhile, has said “It wouldn’t serve any purpose to reopen an investigation.” The problem is that the controversy has already been reopened for them and the initial 2018 investigation is bleeding credibility.

Collapse of the highest order

The situation facing Cricket Australia is stark: competing versions of the truth, a daily drip feed of statements and speculation, accusations of a botched investigation, and an Australian public dragged back into the rumour mill.
Cricket Australia are a kite in the wind.

These are the hallmarks of a reputational meltdown slipping beyond an institution’s control. Everyone involved has retreated into self-protection. Allegations and denials are being traded publicly. The gap between what happened and what people believe happened grows more cavernous by the day.

Silence is not a neutral position. It is surrendering control.

A grown-up innings is required

For those sitting around the table at Cricket Australia, the choice is simple: stick or twist.

Playing a flat bat

The organisation could fall back on a familiar defence. Sandpapergate happened eight years ago, an investigation was conducted, punishments were imposed and there is little value in relitigating a national scandal.

That position may appear safe, but it is increasingly untenable. New claims prompt new denials. Every interview with a current or former player creates another potential headline. The cacophony grows, not quietens.

This Australian side is also entering a period of transition. If the dispute continues through the next Test series and towards the Ashes, Cricket Australia risks being blamed for allowing an off-field crisis to infect performances on it.

They cannot call the batters in before tea and declare the matter closed.

Enforcing the follow-on

Cricket Australia can’t stay silent – the box of Schrodinger’s Cat has been opened and two versions of the truth can no longer co-exist. The 2018 investigation can no longer answer the big questions and the process itself is increasingly seen as a sham.

CEO Todd Greenberg announced today that Cricket Australia will open an independent forum for all those who were on the 2018 South African tour. This is a start but is unlikely to keep the hounds at bay.

Cricket Australia must go further. The organisation does not need to announce a new disciplinary investigation but should commission a tightly defined, independent review of the 2018 process.

Who was interviewed? What evidence was tested? Do subsequent accounts materially change the picture?

This is not necessarily about finding fresh guilt. It is about acknowledging external scrutiny of the 2018 investigation and answering the questions left hanging. There are now too many for Cricket Australia to sandpaper over the cracks.

Its window is narrowing. People care more about Australian cricket than its governing body. For now, the spotlight remains on the players, but it is rapidly turning towards the institution that investigated them.

The impending retirement of several players involved in the 2018 series adds urgency. As Khawaja has demonstrated, retirement can loosen tongues previously constrained by contracts and dressing-room relationships. Without a credible process, revelations will continue to emerge, with each one dragging the crisis back to the surface.

The process should therefore begin before the next Test series. Its first priorities should be appointing an independent chair, preserving the evidence and providing a confidential route through which current and former players can contribute. They should Set a tight timeline for the review, agree to publish the results in full and commit to adhere to or take action resulting from the review. Cricket Australia must take command of the situation, and fast.

The lesson reaches far beyond cricket.

For any organisation facing a revived controversy, the objective cannot be to defend every aspect of its original response. Nor should asking legitimate questions about the process be mistaken for accepting every allegation as true.

Ending speculation and establishing facts is the only way to see off a media maelstrom.

Ending speculation and establishing facts is the only way to see off a media maelstrom. A crisis rarely ends because an organisation says it is over. It ends when stakeholders believe the important questions have been answered.

Cricket Australia should heed the advice given to its players: on a sticky wicket, you must face down every last ball.